The List, which was established in 2007, is used as a guide by business schools around the world to assess the quality of the journals in which faculty members research is published. 5 To place the scope of the 2019 Journal Quality List into a broader perspective, the Australian Research Councils Excellence in Research for Australia (ERA) 2018 Journal List1 which is not a ranking list but does include journals eligible for submission in the 2018 ERA has 3,365 journals across the Field of Research codes covered by the 2019 JQL. An independent chair and discipline-specific panels reviewed the ABDC Journal Quality Listin 2013and 2009. . Members of the expert panels, including the Panel Chair, should be selected through a formal call for Expressions of Interest. 9 Outcomes A detailed summary by each Panels response to eligible submissions4 (which closed on 31 May) can be found in Appendix 1.5 These responses include recommended journal upgrades, downgrades, removal of journals, selected changes to FoR classification for individual outlets, and referrals of several submissions to other Panels. Quality Management Quality Management System Integration This m, HITECH SYSTEMS PFE PVT LTD ITEM NO The processes will be similar to those used by the Australian Research Council for Panel selection. This provided the option for submissions to add a new journal, remove a journal, upgrade a journal, downgrade a journal, and change the FoR of a journal. Information about the panel chairs and panellists is detailed below. Continue to rate as B Stays as B International Review of Research in Open and Distributed Learning Athabasca University 1492-3831 N/A Less than 50% business content. 7 6. From 2012 to 2015, Stephen also served as Chair of BARDsNet, the ABDC network of Australian and New Zealand business ADRs. I am pleased to announce that the 2019 Australian Business Deans Council (ABDC) Journal Quality List and its accompanying Report are now available here. James research focuses on the empirical analysis of business cycles, stabilisation policy, and sources of persistent changes in macroeconomic and financial conditions. The removal of 241 journals from the previous (2016) ABDC List is the result of a careful focus to ensure that the 2019 List reflects currency and continues to assist business researchers to target appropriate, quality outlets for their work. Business Schools Support Chinese Students Impacted by Coronavirus, International Network Executive Committee, Professional Managers Network Executive Committee, Business Academic Research Directors Network (BARDsNet), National Indigenous Business Summer School Victoria, National Indigenous Business Summer School WA, Australian Business Deans Council (ABDC) Journal Quality List, Global Focus Magazine feature on ABDC book that aims to improve academics communication skills, ABDC Journal Quality List: Review of Frequency, Methodology and Scope Recommendations, Business Deans Issue Declaration on Climate Action, Immediate past ABDC President, David Grant, in The Australian on the future opportunities for business schools, Australian Business Deans Appoint New President. Continue to rate as C due to lack of quality indicators Stays as C International Journal of Learning Technology Inderscience Enterprises Limited 1477-8386 N/A Less than 50% business content. A computer science journal Do not add N/A Referred from 1503. Footnote 9 Professor David Grant (President of ABDC and Chair); Professor Chris Styles (Vice President ABDC); Professor Kim Langfield-Smith; Professor Geoff Wood (ABDC JQL International Advisor); Professor Renee Fry-McKibbin, and Professor Andrew ONeil (BARDsNet Chair). Journal quality ratings should be validated by expert panels. Ingrid Nielsen is Head of the Department of Management at Monash University. Mandated under the 2019 JQL Terms of Reference (ToRs), the purpose of the Steering Group was to provide a level of oversight not present in previous reviews. Less than 50% business content Do not add International Journal of Data Science Inderscience Enterprises Limited International Journal of Data Science and Analytics Springer International Journal of Information Technology and Web Engineering IGI Global 1554-1045 C Not new. Technical telecom content Do not add Telecommuniations Policy Elsevier 0308-5961 N/A Not an IS journal Do not add The Internet and Higher Education Elsevier 1096-7516 N/A Less than 50% business content. Our 38 members graduate one-third of all Australian university students and more than half of the nations international tertiary students. Copyright All Rights Reserved 2019 | Website by, International Network Executive Committee, Professional Managers Network Executive Committee, Business Academic Research Directors Network (BARDsNet), National Indigenous Business Summer School Victoria, National Indigenous Business Summer School WA, Steering Group submits draft final list to ABDC for approval, ABDC Executive Committee endorses the recommendations, Professor Neil Fargher, Australian National University, Professor Anne Wyatt, University of Queensland, Professor Lisa Marriot, Victoria University of Wellington, Professor Brett Freudenberg, Griffith University, Professor Jenny Buchan, University of New South Wales, Professor Philip Grossman, Monash University, Associate Professor Rasheda Khanam, University of Southern Queensland, Professor Sandy Suardi, University of Wollongong, Professor Millicent Chang, University of Wollongong, Professor Hazel Bateman, University of New South Wales, Professor Jerry Parwada,University of New South Wales, Professor Alexander Richter, Victoria University of Wellington, Associate Professor Sabine Matook, University of Queensland, Associate Professor John Venable, Curtin University, Professor Neil Ashkanasy, University of Queensland, Professor Shayne Gary, University of New South Wales, Professor Jane Lu, University of Melbourne, Professor Tava Olsen, University of Auckland, Professor Adrian Wilkinson, Griffith University, Professor Chris Wright, University of Sydney, Professor Ingrid Nielsen (Chair), Monash University, Professor Jarrod Haar, Auckland University of Technology, Professor Geoff Soutar, University of Western Australia, Dr Jungkeun Kim, AucklandUniversity of Technology, Professor Marianna Sigala, University of South Australia, New journals started since 1 January 2011, Change of Field of Research (FoR) grouping, Have reached the necessary quality threshold level, as determined by the expert panel using globally accepted, externally validated journal ranking lists, journal citation metrics and expert peer review, Adhere to general scholarly principles, including scholarly peer review, Be relevant to the discipline areas of the ABDC, which include management, accounting, economics, information systems, business and taxation law and other agreed Fields of Research (FoRs), The ABDC will provide appropriate levels of administrative support so panel members should not expect to make significant time commitments to the Journal Quality List Review. walker thomas faculty concordia The Review Panel provided a report to the ABDC in which they outlined six specific recommendations. The ABDC Journal Quality List 2013 comprised 2,767 different journal titles, dividedintofour categories of quality: In each Field of Research (FoR) group,journals deemedNOTto reach thequality thresholdlevelare not listed. T: +61 (0)2 6162 2970 E:office@abdc.edu.au. When evaluating a journals ranking on the List, the Panel referred to internationally recognised and externally validated journal ranking lists (including the ACPHIS List), appropriate and select citations metrics such as SCImago as well as discipline quality and relevance indicators such as editorial boards and publication disciplinary focus. The ABDC Journal Ranking List has been in existence for just over a decade, so it is opportune to reassess its process in terms of the frequency of review, methodology, and scope. Professor Monroe is an internationally renowned researcher in auditing with an emphasis on audit judgment and the economics of auditing, and financial reporting. In accordance with the ToRs, the Steering Group took responsibility for the final JQL recommendations submitted to the ABDC Executive. A journal must: 3. The panels should be informed by globally recognised and externally validated journal ranking lists[1], appropriate and select citation metrics (e.g. More explicit and rigorous processes for the ranking of journals should be developed and reported. The List is significant because the status of researchers work, their career advancement and the international rankings of universities are closely tied to publication and citations in quality academic journals. The list assessed journals relating to Business and Taxation Law, Economics, Finance including Actuarial Studies, Information Systems, Management, Commercial Services and Transport and Logistics, Marketing and Tourism. . A**) should not be added to the ABDC Journal List to recognise world elite journals deemed to be the best in the world. During 2016-17, Stephen served as the inaugural Australian Business Deans Council (ABDC) Research Scholar, a position focused on improving the quality and impact of research in Australian business schools, as well as research training. In April, the ABDC announced the chairs of the eight panels that will rank academic journals in its major 2019 Journal Quality List Review. All journals on the List must meet the substantive business element test and fall within relevant Australia and New Zealand Fields of Research (FoR) codes. In 2016, the ABDC authorised an interim review of the Journal Quality List. In 2011, she took up a prestigious ARC Queen Elizabeth II Fellowship. The primary submitter must have been a representative of one of three relevant stakeholder groups: (a) A Business School/Faculty located in ANZ, or a non-business school or faculty located in ANZ deemed to have a legitimate interest in the disciplines covered by the ABDC Journal Quality List; (b) A relevant Peak Body representing ANZ academics (where such a body is located in ANZ); or (c) An individual academic or groups of like-minded academics with formal affiliation(s) to a university/universities based in ANZ (each signatory must have a relevant minimum of 0.4 FTE position). . Note: Terms of Reference for each of the expert panels should be developed by ABDCs Business Research Deans Network, BARDsNet, and then approved by the ABDC Executive. Strongly debatable whether journal is business (50% of articles over three years written by business faculty, or >50% of articles over three years being of a business nature. I would like to acknowledge the contribution of Dr Kim Langfield-Smith, Principal at Nous Group, and Professor Geoffrey Wood, from the UK Chartered Association of Business Schools to this project. More explicit and rigorous processes for the ranking of journals should be developed and reported. It is just over a decade since we launched the Journal Quality List and so, in the second half of 2020, ABDC will be calling for feedback from key stakeholders as part of a review into the Lists frequency, methodology, and scope. SCImago) and, if required, expert peer review. The removal of journals, which appeared on the 2016 List, is the result of a careful focus to ensure that the revised JQL reflects currency and captures genuine quality outlets that meet the substantive business 4 element test, and fall within the relevant Field of Research codes. INFORMATION SYSTEMS (covering journals across 0806), Professor Deborah Bunker, University of Sydney. James Morley was appointed as Professor of Macroeconomics at the University of Sydney in 2017 and is Co-Director of the Global Perspectives on Economic Policy initiative for the Faculty of Arts & Social Sciences. It has a strong editorial board and impact metrics. 12 Annals of Applied Probability was re-ranked from A* to A in light of metrics and relative standing in the field. After considering feedback, Panel Chairs confirmed their recommendations on behalf of each Panel in early November 2019. . We wish to thank the seven Panel Chairs for their outstanding leadership, the Panel members for their significant work, and the members of the ABDC Steering Group for their important input during the review process. We are confident that the highest standards and most efficient process will be applied to this years full review, which follows a last years review of the methodology that underpins the influential Journal Quality List.. Learn how we and our ad partner Google, collect and use data. Editors are all in health IEEE Transactions on Industrial Informatics IEEE N/A Less than 50% information systems content Do not add IEEE Transactions on Information Theory IEEE 0018-9448 N/A Less than 50% business or information systems content Do not add Industrial Management & Data Systems Emerald Group Publishing 0263-5577 N/A Yes Include due to applicable coverage, and rate as A due to quality indicators Add as A Information Discovery and Delivery Emerald Group Publishing 2398-6247 N/A Related to education and library science Add as C Information Polity IOS Press 1570-1255 N/A New journal and quality indicators not sufficiently developed to rank higher than C Add as C Information Research University of Bors 1368-1613 N/A Yes to include, but rate as C due to lack of quality indicators Add as C 0806 Submissions to Add Journals 16 International Journal of Business Intelligence Inderscience Enterprises Limited and Data Mining (IJBIDM) N/A Less than 50% business content. Possibly consider rating as a general Business Education journal Do not add Computers & Industrial Engineering Elsevier 0360-8352 N/A Low information systems content. Therefore, the BARDsNet Chair, who will lead the process review in the second half of 2020, will invite feedback from key stakeholder groups, including those directly involved in the 2019 Review for example Panel and Steering Group members as well as ABDC members, the academy, and publishers. The ABDC Journal Quality List review process. A health journal Do not add 0806 Submissions to Add Journals 2053-0811 17 Library Management Emerald Group Publishing 0143-5124 N/A A library science journal. However, in considering the issue of ranking inflation, it is also worth reflecting on the nature of specific journals. deans council On 23 September, the ABDC released a draft of the Journal Ranking List and invited feedback by 18 October. Here is the 2019Australian Business Deans Council (ABDC) Journal Quality Listand its accompanyingReport. She was formerly Alfred Deakin Professor of Management and Pro Vice-Chancellor (Research Performance) at Deakin University. The inaugural version of the ABDC Journal Quality List was released in 2008 and updated in 2010. A computer science journal Do not add Journal of Business Analytics Taylor & Francis Online 2573-234X N/A Yes include, but at level C. Brand new, excellent EIC and editorial board, no track record Add as C Journal of Cases on Information Technology IGI Global 1548-7717 N/A Yes to include, but at level C. Insufficient grounds regarding quality and business indicators to rank higher Add as C Journal of Documentation Emerald Group Publishing 0022-0418 N/A A library science journal. These recommendations were provided to the ABDC Office in early September. It probably should have been at least B if not A in the previous 2016 List. Andrew ONeil BARDsNet Chair 18 February 2019 97. Julie-Anne has served as the General Manager, CEO or Director of a range of organisations including the Queensland Institute of Medical Research; Indiana Universitys International Programs Office; USP Solutions (the private commercial arm of the University of the South Pacific); and the Litigation Reform Commission (Qld). After taking into account the expert review and feedback from BARDsNet,the ABDC endorsed the following methodology: 1. Stephen was a member of the Excellence in Research for Australia (ERA) panel for Economics and Business for the 2015 and 2018 assessments. In nearly all cases, the best quality research appears in journals that are recognised as the best quality outlets. 5 Note that all eligible submissions to the 2019 JQL process will be posted on the ABDC website in 2020. PRICE + GST EXTRA 8 10 The following journal was removed from the List due to an earlier inaccurate interpretation of the 0806 Panel decision, which was not to include this outlet following a referral from the 1503 Panel: Telecommunications Policy The following journal was withdrawn from the List at the request of the journal editor (and with agreement of the 1503 Panel Chair): Vikalpa Following further analysis, the following journals were removed (endorsed by the relevant Panel Chairs) because they did not meet the required quality threshold: Accounting and Finance Research Asian Economic and Financial Review Asian Journal of Empirical Research Asian Journal of Finance and Accounting Asian Social Science Asian-African Journal of Economics and Econometrics Cuadernos de Economa Spanish Journal of Economics and Finance Global Business and Finance Review Indian Journal of Economics and Business International Journal of Accounting and Financial Reporting International Journal of Ecological Economics and Statistics International Journal of Economic Research International Journal of Statistics and Economics Review of Applied Economics Review of Economics & Finance The following entries were removed from the List (endorsed by relevant Panel Chairs) because they are no longer published as journals or cannot be confirmed as current publications: Accounting, Commerce and Finance: The Islamic Perspective Journal Advances in Financial Education Advances in Futures and Options Research Advances in Quantitative Analysis of Finance and Accounting Applied Financial Economic Letters Asia Pacific Economic Papers Asia Pacific Population Journal Bank of Valletta Review Brookings Wharton Papers on Financial Services Casualty Actuarial Society Forum Economic and Financial Review Emergo 11 Employment Relations Record Finance Letters Financial Decisons Greek Economic Review International Journal of Asian Management International Journal of Productivity and Quality Management International Studies in Economics and Econometrics Investment Policy IZA Journals Journal of Construction Research Journal of Corporate Treasury Management Journal of Finance and Financial Services Journal of Finance and Management in Public Services Transport Engineering in Australia The ABDC Steering Group9 met on 21 November to review the final recommendations of the Panels. But the rigorousness of its editorial process places it as an A journal. The operational task of the Steering Group was to identify any anomalies in the Panel recommendations with a view to recommending a Final List for submission to the ABDC Executive. NBFC Report 2019 Like previous exercises, it is the result of a comprehensive Panel-led review in accordance with detailed Terms of Reference approved by the ABDC (see Appendix 2). In other words, it is worth considering the relative thickness and frequency of individual journals as well as simply the overall number of A and A* journals. Excellent for a relatively new journal Add as A Applied Mathematical Modelling Elsevier 0307-904X N/A Less than 50% business content Do not add Asia Pacific Journal of Information Systems Korea Society of Management Information Systems 2288-5404 N/A Include, but insufficient evidence to rate higher than C Add as C Aslib Journal of Information Management Emerald Group Publishing 2050-3806 N/A Add as B based on quality indicators Add as B Big Data and Cognitive Computing MDPI 2504-2289 N/A Less than 50% business content Do not add Clinical Infectious Diseases Oxford University Press 1058-4838 N/A Less than 50% business content Do not add Computers & Education Elsevier 0360-1315 N/A Less than 50% business content. . It is important to underscore that the Steering Group review was the penultimate step in the 2019 JQL process before the final step of the ABDC Executive endorsing the 2019 JQL. We're not around right now. Professor Bunker is a Multi-Disciplinary Advisory Board Member of the Marie Bashir Institute (MBI) at the University of Sydney. A**) should not be added to the ABDC Journal List to recognise world elite journals deemed to be the best in the world 5. Administration will include a Research Assistant to support gathering data on each journal, There should be between five and eight expert panels as the panels do not need to mirror the FORs, The size of each panel should reflect the number and size of the disciplines represented on it. It is undoubtedly easier to upgrade journals than to downgrade them. Ingrid is an appointed Research Fellow of the Australian and New Zealand Academy of Management and an appointed Business Management Specialist in the Hong Kong Council for Accreditation of Academic and Vocational Qualifications.She holds a current ARC Discovery Grant and her research has received funding from the Department of Foreign Affairs and Trade, Department of Health and Human Services, Academy of the Social Sciences in Australia, and the Data to Decisions CRC. Journal quality ratings should be validated by Expert Panels. She has previously held senior appointments in the United States, Australia (where she has taught at Monash, Bond and University of Queensland) and the University of the South Pacific. She is a member of the NSW Office of Environment and Heritage funded, Human Health and Social Impacts Node, which is hosted at the University of Sydney. The initial list aimed to overcome the regional and discipline bias of international lists. BUSINESS AND TAXATION LAW (covering journals across 180105 and 1801025), Professor Julie-Anne Tarr, Queensland University of Technology. These will include predatory/illegitimate outlets. We wish to thank the seven Panel Chairs for their outstanding leadership, the Panel members for their significant work, and the members of the ABDC Steering Group for their important input during the review process. In the vast majority of instances, the Steering Group agreed with the Panel Chairs justifications for their recommendations. Could include as general business education relevant Do not add JAMA Internal Medicine American Medical Association 2168-6106 N/A Less than 50% business content Do not add JMIR mHealth and uHealth JMIR PUBLICATIONS, INC 2291-5222 N/A Less than 50% business content Do not add Journal of Biomedical Informatics Elsevier 1532-0464 N/A Less than 50% business content. 2. In accordance with the Terms of Reference (ToRs), Chairs consulted with fellow Panel members only where they judged it necessary. All journals on the List must meet the substantive business element test and fall within relevant Australia and New Zealand Fields of Research (FoR) codes. 3 June 30 August Panels review submissions, 31 August All draft panel recommendations to ABDC Steering Group, 23 September ABDC releases draft Journal Ranking List, 18 October Deadline for feedback on draft Journal Ranking List, Panels submit recommendations to ABDC Steering Group, which consultswith International Advisor, 6 DecemberABDC 2019 Journal Quality List released, ACCOUNTING (covering journals across 1501), Professor Gary Monroe, University of New South Wales. It also thanks members of the ABDC Steering Group for their important contributions to the JQL review process. . In instances where there was a Panel member conflict of interest, independent expert peer review was undertaken external to the Panel. Ronald F. Clayton In addition to responding to these submissions, the Panels themselves retained the option of initiating decisions about individual journals. He serves on the Editorial Boards of a number of international journals. In 2007, ABDC established the ABDC Journal Quality List for use by its member business schools. . Have a brigh career ahead and I wish you all the best !! Stephen Taylor is UTS Distinguished Professor of Accounting at the University of Technology Sydney and is also a member of the Australian Accounting Standards Board. MARKETING AND TOURISM (covering journals across 1505-1506), Professor Sara Dolnicar, University of Queensland. EMIGR, Quality 15 0806 SUBMISSIONS TO ADD JOURNALS Title Publisher ISSN Current Rating Reviewer Comments Decision/ Outcome AIS Transactions on Human-Computer Interaction Association for Information Systems 1944-3900 N/A Adequate grounds on quality and citation indicators and business focus to include at level A. For details, see https://www.arc.gov.au/excellence-research-australia/era-2018-journal-list 2 The 2018 AJG is available at: https://charteredabs.org/academic-journal-guide-2018/ 6 Method and Approach In early 2018, the ABDC appointed Emeritus Professor Kim Langfield-Smith and Professor Geoffrey Wood to review the methodology for a future ABDC Journal Quality List. After this consultation with Panel Chairs, the Steering Group made the following specific amendments to the Journal Quality List: Journal of Sport Management and Sport Management Review were both re-ranked to A in light of metrics and relative standing in the field. Prior to taking up his appointment at UNSW, Gary worked at the Australian National University, Edith Cowan University, University of Western Australia, University of Hawaii, Duke University and the University of Massachusetts. But you can send us an email and we'll get back to you, asap. He received his PhD from the University of Washington in 1999 and previously held positions at Washington University in St. Louis and the University of New South Wales, most recently as Associate Dean (Research) of the UNSW Business School from 2014-2017. . Please click here to download a copy of the terms of reference for the 2019 review. . Our partners will collect data and use cookies for ad personalization and measurement. The ABDC will provide appropriate levels of administrative support so Panel members should not expect to make significant time commitments to the Journal Quality List Review. In 2019, for the first time in the history of the ABDC Journal Quality List, the number of journals removed from the List has exceeded the number added. About the Australia, District and State wise list of Active RA(Recruiting Agents) as on 25-02-2019 (DD-MM-YYYY) RAID(AS GIVEN IN S. No. The processes will besimilar to those used by the Australian Research Council for panel selection. Noting that the recommended ranking moves up to two places since 2016, the Panel Chair (ACCT) provided the following justification: When we read the papers, we thought they were similar to other A ranked papers in terms of quality. islamic finance marketing management advances perspective asian . It includes 144 upgrades; 17 downgrades; the addition of 157 new journals; and the removal of 241 journals. Background and Context Rigorous peer review lies at the heart of scholarly progress. T: +61 (0)2 6162 2970 E:office@abdc.edu.au. Most recommendations were in response to eligible submissions, but in a number of cases they were initiated by the Panels themselves. FINANCE (including Actuarial Studies) (covering journals across 1502), Professor Stephen Taylor, University of Technology Sydney. The 2019 Journal Quality List builds on this process. UNSW Business School, Deans Unit, Level 6, West Lobby, College Road, Kensington, NSW, Australia 2052 While the quality of journals is evidenced by metrics such as citation rates and impact factors, peer judgements also play an important role in determining the esteem of an individual journal. May new year 2020 will bring great news to you and your research team in research and teaching (academics), consulting projects.